How We Evaluate Ereaders
Short version: we have not yet tested any e-reader hands-on. Our reviews are research-based. This page explains what that means, where each kind of claim comes from, and how we plan to test.
The five kinds of evidence
| Evidence | Status on this site | How it is presented |
|---|---|---|
| Hands-on testing by us | Not yet conducted | No ratings, scores or benchmark figures are published |
| Manufacturer specifications | Used for every product | Stated as facts, with sources; battery life labeled as a claim |
| Independent third-party testing | Used where available | Attributed by name to the publication, with a link |
| Editorial assessment | Used for every recommendation | Labels such as “best for library readers”; clearly opinion |
| User feedback | Not used | We show no customer ratings or review counts |
What we check for each product
- The exact model and generation currently on sale.
- Display technology, size, resolution and pixel density.
- Dimensions, weight, storage and water-protection rating.
- The manufacturer’s battery claim and its stated conditions.
- Supported file formats and library compatibility.
- List price and the retailer page it came from.
- At least two independent hands-on reviews, for strengths and criticisms.
Each fact is recorded once in a central product database with its source and the date we verified it. Every product card, table, review and comparison on the site reads from that record, so a specification cannot say one thing on one page and something else on another.
What we could not verify
Some facts cannot be confirmed from the sources we can reach. When that happens we say so on the review under “What we could not verify”, and we leave the value out of tables instead of guessing. Where a price could not be verified, we show no price.
Why there are no ratings
A score implies measurement. We have none of our own, and averaging other publications’ scores would present their work as ours. Each review therefore gives a written verdict, who the device is and is not for, and its strengths and limitations.
How we intend to test
When we begin hands-on testing, each published result will state the measurement, the conditions, the date, the method and its limitations. The areas we plan to cover are display clarity and contrast, front-light uniformity, page-turn responsiveness, battery endurance under a stated reading pattern, weight and ergonomics, software usability and file compatibility. Reviews will be relabeled as partially or fully tested only when that work has been done.
The illustrations
Product images on this site are schematic illustrations that we draw to scale from each device’s published dimensions and screen size. They are not photographs, and they do not show finishes or fine details. We use them because we do not hold licenses for manufacturer or third-party photography.
Questions about our method? Contact us. See also the editorial policy.